The Verdict:
The Starlight show, surprisingly, sees us back yet again in one-jam land. Despite the reputation of this tour, I'm finding a lot of these less consistent shows as I listen through. 8/5 is definitely more reminiscent of 8/2, 7/29, 7/28, or 7/21 than one of the stronger entries thus far this year.
I guess if you like the composed classics, you get "Divided Sky" and "YEM" here. Otherwise you get a first set that has a 2010-era half and a 2015-era half, each bolstered by even-better-than-usual-for-2015 Trey solos, but also never interested in making any moves out of the usual first set box. Unless you count the Phish debut of Mike's "The Last Step," which was oddly placed in the set but really well played and suited to the band, I thought.
The second set is extra weird. It starts with Type I takes on "Jibboo" and "Twist" (huh?) before dropping "The Wedge" to ensure jamming blue balls. Then, out of nowhere, there's a monster "Disease" that's long and patiently developed and doesn't predictably freak out into a peak at the last second. It's definitely worth a listen. The "Sand" that follows is short, but is in the mold of last year's "Mike's" from Dick's. I really love this kind of jamming, but it leans entirely on the echo effect for the length of the jam, so your mileage will vary. The second set ends with a particularly-unearned-seeming "YEM," and though of course it's a strong version, it doesn't exactly bring anything new to the table.
Starlight isn't a bad show by any means, and I'd be happy to have it in 2014 or any previous year. But it seems a bit out of character for 2015, where none of the qualities that have characterized the many great moments of the tour so far (improvisation in strange places, clever segues, unexpected setlist choices, unexpected jam vehicles, multiple deep jams per show) are on display. You should listen to the "Disease" and the "Sand," though. Here they are:
The Live Review:
8/5/15: After a somewhat uneven 8/4 (albeit with an awesome finish), it's time for 8/5!
8/5/15: Trey noodling something at the opening. Sounded sort of like The Horse but in a major key.
8/5/15: 'They Attack!' sample from Page.
8/5/15: Really slow Gumbo to start.
8/5/15: Really liking the slow-down, actually.
8/5/15: Clav solo outro with some interesting drumming from Fish.
8/5/15: KDF next.
8/5/15: Trey is destroying this KDF.
8/5/15: In a good way, I mean.
8/5/15: Back on the Train. What is it about this song that makes it seem like the most predictable of predictable songs?
8/5/15: It's actually really catchy, but every time it pops up, I immediately think 'Oh, this shit again.'
8/5/15: Except this time: https://t.co/rErltddPIU
8/5/15: I love that the only real jammed-out BOTT is a fucking ten-minute-long ambient jam.
8/5/15: Makes no sense, and that's why it's great.
8/5/15: Okay, despite my bitching, that was an excellent Trey-heavy BOTT.
8/5/15: Bouncin', Divided Sky.
8/5/15: I feel like this first set, so far at least, is a sort of 2009-2010 set, in terms of song choices.
8/5/15: It reminds me of reviewing a 2010 show, though with MUCH stronger playing from everyone.
8/5/15: Here's a fun fact: DSky has been playing once every four shows on average. I've seen 29 shows and heard it once. #phish #cursed
8/5/15: *played
8/5/15: Holy crap! The Last Step!
8/5/15: The Phish version of the song seems more sinister for some reason.
8/5/15: That was surprisingly well-played.
8/5/15: Blaze On!
8/5/15: Nice in-the-box Blaze On.
8/5/15: Seems like a weird placement for WAN.
8/5/15: Rock-heavy 46 Days to close the set. Trey is losing his mind.
8/5/15: That first set was pretty weird. First half = 2010, second half = 2015. Both halves were clearly assembled using a dart board.
8/5/15: Some great Trey solos in BOTT, Blaze On, and 46 Days, though.
8/5/15: Now the second set opens with Jibboo. Even weirder.
8/5/15: One thing that I do always love about Jibboo is Mike's bass.
8/5/15: Jibboo > Twist.
8/5/15: Trey just shredded Twist into the ground. Sure, it's another Type I solo in the usual jam slot, but it's a good 'un.
8/5/15: The Wedge: the surprise S2 blue-baller of 2015.
8/5/15: Standard The Wedge > Pop Goes The Weasel tease from Mike > DWD.
8/5/15: Maybe 2015 Phish (not just Trey) will finally make an appearance here tonight.
8/5/15: Disease jam getting interesting around 8 mins. Loops coming in and Trey playing melody around them.
8/5/15: Really mesmerizing, loopy bassline from Mike. Now Page over to electric piano.
8/5/15: Trey and Mike playing off of each other.
8/5/15: Trey has a nice riff going now.
8/5/15: Droning synth from Page.
8/5/15: This is staying pretty mellow. At 14 mins. now. Trey chording. Page back on piano.
8/5/15: Turning darker now.
8/5/15: How Trey is containing himself from doing a > Rift is beyond me.
8/5/15: Trey's got a rising chord pattern going now. Fish is picking up steam. Should be a strong ending to the jam.
8/5/15: Pure guitar rage now.
8/5/15: Trey over to the loops AND the pitch-shifter now.
8/5/15: Sand!
8/5/15: Echo-funk chording a la the Dick's Mike's in 2014.
8/5/15: This is great.
8/5/15: Joy. The Disease > Sand pair was the 1st part of the show that really
seemed to have a lot of momentum, so that's sort of a bummer.
8/5/15: YEM, out of friggin' nowhere.
8/5/15: I mean, I love YEM, obviously, but it seems like one of those coup de grace songs.
8/5/15: It's weird to hear it at the end of a show that has been pretty underwhelming (at least by 2015 standards).
8/5/15: Though two old school, composed monsters in one show is nice, I suppose.
8/5/15: Maybe I'm just experiencing Magnaball > Dick's syndrome since listening to the Atlanta run, though.
8/5/15: Maybe I'm shitting on (most of) 8/4 and (all of) 8/5 not because they're bad but because Atlanta was so good.
8/5/15: Pretty badass YEM jam going on here.
8/5/15: One thing's for sure: YEM might be a rarity lately, and might show up in weird places, but the YEM jams have been great.
8/5/15: Bug encore.
8/5/15: Woo! Eight more shows till Magnaball!
No comments:
Post a Comment